How to Choose a Performance Marketing Agency for iGaming: What to Look for and Which Red Flags You Shouldn’t Ignore

At first glance, there are plenty of options. Performance marketing agencies showcase case studies, promise to reduce CPA, increase ROI, and scale campaigns. But what really matters is understanding what a contractor can actually do for your business.

After all, iGaming has its own rules. Results depend on GEO (geography), advertising platform restrictions, compliance requirements, product specifics, and audience behavior.

That’s why SVET has prepared a step-by-step guide. We’ll explore how choosing a performance marketing agency for iGaming differs from other industries, what to look for when evaluating a contractor, which questions to ask during the pitch, and which red flags shouldn’t be ignored.

Why a One-Size-Fits-All Approach to Choosing an Agency Doesn’t Work in iGaming

At the stage of choosing a contractor, it can sometimes be difficult to understand what actually stands behind a strong presentation and impressive case studies. A portfolio matters, but it may not be enough. It’s important to check how closely the agency’s experience matches your specific product, GEO and business objectives.

Pay attention to communication as well. How clearly does the team explain its decisions? Do they ask questions about the product and funnel before recommending channels and forecasting results? Do they discuss not only the potential but also the risks and limitations?

Here are a few criteria that can help you choose a potential contractor.

1. Think Long Term

Performance marketing is a system, not a one-off launch. The team needs time to understand the product, review analytics, test hypotheses, eliminate approaches that don’t work, and identify opportunities for scaling.

It’s better to choose a team you can work with consistently to analyze results and develop what actually works.

2. Check Relevant Experience

You need to understand which iGaming products the agency has worked with, what challenges it has addressed, what budgets it has managed, and which metrics it was responsible for.

Agencies often share this information on their websites or showcase it in their portfolios. If there isn’t enough information, don’t hesitate to ask.

3. Look for Experience in Your Target GEO

For iGaming, experience in a specific GEO is particularly important. Markets differ not only in traffic costs but also in regulatory requirements, advertising platform policies, the competitive landscape, and user behavior. The team should understand these specifics and know how to work with them.

Case Studies Matter

Specific case studies help you see not only the final result but also the logic behind the agency’s approach.

One of SVET clients was launching a new crash game. The product was ready for promotion, but media buyers were not yet familiar with it and were not running the offer.

‍

The team created a dedicated landing page for buyers and launched ads targeting audiences from relevant iGaming conferences. They also added remarketing and promotion on Telegram. As a result, the landing page attracted 6,821 users, while 2,058 webmasters downloaded the game’s promotional materials.

After that, buyers started running the offer. The game’s creatives appeared on spy tools, where other market participants could see them. The product reached the top positions in two GEO, while in certain GEO, 65% of its creatives appeared on the first pages.

‍

This created a snowball effect. Buyers saw that others were already working with the offer and started testing it themselves, which attracted new webmasters and increased the number of organic inquiries.

This case study shows much more than a single ROI figure: what challenge the team addressed, which channels it combined, and how one result became the driver for the next.

‍

A strong case study is already a good sign. If you still have questions after reviewing it or want to learn more, ask for details during the pitch stage. This will help you better understand the agency’s experience and assess how well its approach fits your business.

What Questions to Ask an Agency Before Starting a Partnership

At this stage, it’s important to maintain a balance. You need to get enough information about the agency’s working approach while also taking the specifics of the industry into account. In iGaming, there will be some data the team genuinely cannot disclose due to NDA.

That’s why both the numbers they show you and the way the team explains its decisions and answers your questions matter.

‍

Here’s what you should ask:

• What data do you need from us before launch to assess the current situation?
• How do you determine whether the problem is in the advertising rather than the product, offer, landing page, or later stages of the funnel?
• What criteria do you use to decide whether to stop a campaign, continue testing, or scale it?
• What do you do if CPA starts to increase while the quality of acquired users declines?
• What restrictions have you encountered in our geography, and how did you work with them within platform policies?

Communication should work both ways. So it’s perfectly normal if the agency also asks a lot of questions during negotiations. A strong performance marketing team will want to understand your product, unit economics, funnel, current metrics, and limitations.

Red Flags: What to Watch Out For

Warning signs that raise concerns at the beginning can later turn into systemic problems or even lead to the end of the partnership. That’s why it’s better to question any doubtful claims before the agency gets access to your advertising budgets.

‍

Here are a few common examples:

‍

[table]

If the agency says: | What you should clarify:  

We guarantee a specific ROI | What data is this guarantee based on? 

We work with any GEO | What experience do you have in the specific market we need? 

We’ll cut CPA in half | How will you achieve this, and how long will it take? 

Need to double the advertising budget | What data were used to calculate these metrics?

[/table]

‍

Another red flag is an unwillingness to discuss risks. In performance marketing, it’s impossible to guarantee the outcome of every hypothesis in advance. A normal working process involves testing, unsuccessful combinations, and strategy adjustments.

How to Know You’ve Found the Right Team

When choosing an agency, it’s worth evaluating several factors together: relevant experience, knowledge of the target geography, case study results, and the team’s approach to work.

This gives you a better chance of building a long-term partnership where decisions are based on data and the advertising budget works toward business objectives.

Want to evaluate your current results or looking for a new contractor?

In that case, it’s worth starting with an audit. The SVET team will analyze your current performance campaigns, funnel, and key metrics. This will help identify where the business is losing results, which decisions need to be reconsidered, and where there is potential for further scaling.